A roundup of Favorite Thanksgiving Pie Recipes to help you up your pie game this Thanksgiving. Whether you like a classic pecan pie, or you’re all about a cool and cream pie, I’ve got you covered.
I love Thanksgiving dinner, but I love Thanksgiving dessert even more. Thanksgiving is the one day when people expect there to be pie, and not just one kind of pie, lots of pies to choose from. In my family we like to have a little taste of all the different kinds of pie available. Does your family do that too?
Recently, I attended a pie party with a few of my talented Utah food blogger friends. We each made a pie or two, or three to share. It was fun getting together, but tasting a little sliver of each pie was definitely the highlight of the party.
FAVORITE THANKSGIVING PIE RECIPES
Whether you like a traditional pie for Thanksgiving or want to try something new, here are lots of delicious options, several with no-bake crusts, to make your Thanksgiving pies extra special this year.1
HOMEMADE PUMPKIN PIE
This Homemade Pumpkin Pie is a must-have Thanksgiving recipe made with real pumpkin purée and warming fall spices. A classic custard pie filling is sure to please everyone around your holiday table. Get RecipeAd Preview2
APPLE CRANBERRY STREUSEL PIE
A mouth watering combination of sweet apples and tart cranberries topped with a crumbly streusel topping. This Apple Cranberry Streusel Pie is the perfect Thanksgiving pie.Get Recipe3
LEMON BLACKBERRY CHESS PIE
A tart Lemon Blackberry Chess Pie with a bright lemon flavor, a layer of blackberries on the bottom and dollops of blackberries swirled on top. Get Recipe4
CHEESECAKE SWIRL PUMPKIN PIE RECIPE
This pie has the flavor of a classic pumpkin pie but with an incredible creamy texture from the cream cheese!Get RecipeAd Preview5
SALTED CARAMEL APPLE PIE WITH STREUSEL TOPPING
This Salted Caramel Apple Pie combines sweet creamy caramel, tart apples, flaky pie crust and a toffee-like streusel topping.Get Recipe6
CREAMY LEMON YOGURT PIE
A Creamy Lemon Yogurt Pie in a crisp graham cracker crust. The easy-to-make lemon filling gets it’s creamy texture and a little extra tang from the addition of Greek yogurt.Get Recipe7
BANANA CREAM PIE – LIKE MOTHER LIKE DAUGHTER
This banana cream pie is the best! With a buttery sweet graham cracker crust, banana pudding filling and topped with whipped cream. Get RecipeAd Preview8
COCONUT CREAM PIE RECIPE AND VIDEO
This coconut cream pie is creamy and full of coconut flavor. In a delicious crust and topped with fresh whipped cream it’s always a favorite.Get Recipe9
CRANBERRY PECAN PIE RECIPE
This Cranberry Pecan Pie is an easy-to-make pie made from fresh cranberries, crunchy pecans, and a sweet pie dough.Get Recipe10
CLASSIC PECAN PIE
Crunchy pecans surrounded by a sweet, rich sticky filling in a flaky pie crust. Pecan pie served with a dollop of fresh, sweetened whipped cream is a classic southern pie and the perfect finish to Thanksgiving dinner.Get RecipeAd Preview11
FRESH TRIPLE BERRY PIE
Fresh strawberries and blackberries covered in a luscious strawberry blueberry glaze served in a golden, flaky pie crust topped with a swirl of whipped cream. Get Recipe12
COCONUT CREAM PIE WITH A CHOCOLATE CRUMB CRUST
A chocolate crumb crust with a luscious, creamy coconut filling drizzled with hot fudge. The flavors of an Almond Joy in a pie.Get Recipe13
CHERRY PIE COOKIES
Cherry Pie Cookies are an easy way to whip up some delicious cookie cups that satisfy your craving for cherry pie, without all the work!Get RecipeAd Preview14
DUTCH CARAMEL APPLE PIE BITES
These Dutch Caramel Apple Pie Bites are a fun, bite-size version of a Dutch apple pie in a flaky, ready-made mini shell with a caramel drizzle on top. Continue Reading15
CRANBERRY PECAN PIE BITES
Luscious, easy-to-make Cranberry Pecan Pie Bites made from fresh cranberries and crunchy pecans in flaky, ready-made mini fillo shells finished with a pretty swirl of whipped cream. Get Recipe16
SOUR CREAM LEMON PIE RECIPE
The best sour cream lemon pie you’ll ever taste. A tart lemon flavor in a creamy pie that everyone loves.Get RecipeAd Preview17
RASPBERRY MERINGUE PIE
This easy-to-make Raspberry Meringue Pie has a filling made with light as air sweet meringue mixed with ruby red raspberries baked in a cookie crust until it’s crisp and golden brown. Get Recipe18
BROWN SUGAR BANANA CREAM PIE
This Brown Sugar Banana Cream Pie takes banana cream pie to a whole new level. An easy to make graham cracker crust is topped with a layer of bananas, luscious homemade brown sugar custard and finished with lightly sweetened whipped cream. Get Recipe19
MINI CHOCOLATE ALMOND COCONUT PIES
Chocolate Almond Coconut Pies are a delicious, bite sized treat. They’re perfect any time of the year, but especially as a holiday dessert! If you like Almond Joy candy bars, you’ll love this mini coconut pies recipe.Get RecipeAd Preview20
FROZEN CHOCOLATE OREO PIE
This Frozen Chocolate Oreo Pie is one of those old-time desserts passed down from neighbor-to-neighbor and that takes you back to the flavors you loved when you were a kid. Get Recipe21
KEY LIME PIE WITH MANGO SAUCE
A tart, creamy key lime pie with a graham cracker crust crowned with a light as air meringue and served with a sweet mango sauce.Get Recipe22
CHOCOLATE COVERED FROZEN KEY LIME PIE BITES
Luscious Chocolate Covered Frozen Key Lime Pie Bites are perfect for summertime entertaining. They’re easy-to-make, no-bake, and require only a few minutes of hands on prep time.Get RecipeAd Preview23
NO BAKE MINI LEMON CREAM CHEESE PIES
These cute little, luscious lemon cream cheese pies are so easy to make – even if you think your pie challenged. If you’re not a lemon lover, use your favorite fruit topping. Continue Reading
I hope we’ve inspired you to try one or two of these pies this Thanksgiving. If you need help making pie crust, I did a post with my best pie crust making tips.
Do you have a favorite Thanksgiving pie that you have to make each year?
2 Sisters Recipes
OH MY! What a fabulous post!! LOve all your pies Barbara , but I think our favorite is your Creamy Lemon Yogurt
Pie! That is on our to-do list next week! Have a wonderful Thanksgiving!
would have really liked to try Jessica Butler mini cherry pies but no print command on her site
That is odd – you can copy and paste the recipe into a word document and print it that way.
Oh my goodness! I love Pies! These sound amazing.
Oh boy…look at all of those decadent pies. I would be hard pressed to choose a favorite. I made a Lemon Sour Cream Pie similar to Ashlee’s a few years ago-that was heavenly. I do love lemon everything.
I’ll be making the pies for Robin’s house this year-that’s usually my job. On the docket for Wednesday is Pumpkin Pie (one for here and one to take)-that’s Stephen’s favorite (and Bob’s), homemade Chocolate Cream Pie-Ray’s favorite, and Raspberry Ribbon Pie-Robin and Nick’s request. That recipe is one my Aunt Jane made when I was growing up and my parents hosted Thanksgiving-it’s one of my favorites too. Every time I make it, I think of her and how much I miss her wonderful meals and desserts. Thank goodness she passed a lot of her recipes along to me.
Have a wonderful Thanksgiving, Barbara!
Thanks Carol! Sounds like you’ll have a great selection. Happy Thanksgiving!